Construction Today - January 2017 - 9

tor's right to rely on the accuracy of the documents. Will courts view
BIM through the same lens and find implied warranties and obligations in the practical requirements of the technology? And will they
similarly refuse to enforce contractual disclaimers and limitations
that are contrary to those realities?
Will courts recognize liability outside the contract; for example,
for negligence? Contractual disclaimers and limitations of liability might not limit or bar such claims. In traditional contracting
arrangements, the main barriers to extra-contractual remedies are
the economic loss doctrine and its close cousin, the gist of the action
doctrine. Where applicable, both prevent a party from attempting
to avoid contract limitations by bringing claim for "negligent"
performance of contractual obligations. But there are recognized
exceptions that might be applied to BIM.

CONSTRUCTION LAW

tor-supplied information, or if the contractor
failed to detect conflicts that should have
been apparent from the modeling, would
it be liable to the architect and/or owner?
Similarly, if the architect failed to address
conflicts between the design and shop drawings or product details, would it be liable for
the costs to correct or the resultant delay?
Proponents assured that BIM could be
implemented while preserving the traditional allocation of risk among owner, designer
and builder. Proposed contract language was
developed that maintained the lack of privity
between designer and contractor, reaffirmed
the architect's sole responsibility for design, and
preserved the owner's liability under Spearin.
Affirmations and disclaimers cannot, however, alter the fact that being able to rely on
the accuracy of shared information is critically important. Recognizing the importance of
ensuring that the information provided was
accurate and reliable would create a duty,
however, and duty usually carries with it liability. But, it was the fear of such liability that
necessitated the affirmations and disclaimers
in the first place. In an attempt to solve this
conundrum, some contracts walk a very fine
line; they acknowledge that each party had
a duty to ensure the information it provides
is accurate, but either disclaims any right to
rely on the information or limits the liability
of the party that provides it.
But will courts give effect to this language,
or will they look past it and assess liability
in accordance with the practical realities?
Given that there have been very few reported
decisions applying or interpreting BIM
contract terms, we simply do not yet know.
There are a number of established legal
theories that could be applied to find liability
despite the contract language, however. To
begin with, it is important to note that the
Spearin Doctrine created an implied duty
based on the realities of the design-bid-build
construction process. Disclaimers of liability
have routinely found to be unenforceable,
and clauses requiring inspection of the site
or review the plans do not lessen the contrac-

Thomas J.
Madigan
is a partner
with
Pepper Hamilton LLP
and a member of the
firm's Construction
and Government
Contracts Practice
Groups. He practices in
commercial litigation,
with an emphasis
on constructionrelated claims. He
also negotiates and

Rules May Not Apply

drafts construction,

First, in some jurisdictions, under certain circumstances, the
doctrines do not apply to the provision of services, particularly
professional services. Therefore, if the sharing of information and
collaboration in the design effort is considered to be a pre-construction or delegated design service, the rules may not apply to preclude
negligence claims.
Second, the doctrines have been held not to apply to the negligent
provision of information. A number of states recognize a cause of
action for the negligent provision of information under §552 of
the Restatement (Second) of Torts, which recognizes claims against
"one who, in the course of his business ... supplies false information
for the guidance of others in their business transactions ... if [the
provider] fails to exercise reasonable care or competence in obtaining or communicating the information." Finally, the doctrines are
generally inapplicable when the claim involves personal injury or
damage to property.

engineering, supply
and other commercial
contracts, and
handles general
commercial litigation
for engineering
and construction
firms, construction
managers, owners and
large manufacturers. 
Madigan is regularly
listed in The Best
Lawyers in America®
and Pennsylvania
Super Lawyers for
Construction Law
and Construction
Litigation, and has an

Make No Assumptions
Given the lack of reported cases interpreting or applying BIM contract language, we do not yet know the answers to these questions.
The purpose of raising them is not to discourage the use of BIM. The
technology is a powerful tool, and is proven to be effective in the
early detection and elimination of design errors and conflicts. In fact,
the lack of reported case law may be a testament to the effectiveness
of the technology.
But, the participants, contractors in particular, cannot casually
use the technology assuming they are protected from liability in the
event that something goes wrong. Each must make a real commitment to participate as a partner in the process and ensure that the
information it contributes is accurate and complete. In other words,
it must actively manage and mitigate the risks of collaboration in
order to fully enjoy its benefits.

AV Preeminent rating by
Martindale-Hubbell®. 
He can be reached at
madigant@pepperlaw.
com.

9

JANUARY 2017 CONSTRUCTION-TODAY.COM


http://www.CONSTRUCTION-TODAY.COM

Table of Contents for the Digital Edition of Construction Today - January 2017

Contents
Construction Today - January 2017 - Cover1
Construction Today - January 2017 - Cover2
Construction Today - January 2017 - 1
Construction Today - January 2017 - 2
Construction Today - January 2017 - Contents
Construction Today - January 2017 - 4
Construction Today - January 2017 - 5
Construction Today - January 2017 - 6
Construction Today - January 2017 - 7
Construction Today - January 2017 - 8
Construction Today - January 2017 - 9
Construction Today - January 2017 - 10
Construction Today - January 2017 - 11
Construction Today - January 2017 - 12
Construction Today - January 2017 - 13
Construction Today - January 2017 - 14
Construction Today - January 2017 - 15
Construction Today - January 2017 - 16
Construction Today - January 2017 - 17
Construction Today - January 2017 - 18
Construction Today - January 2017 - 19
Construction Today - January 2017 - 20
Construction Today - January 2017 - 21
Construction Today - January 2017 - 22
Construction Today - January 2017 - 23
Construction Today - January 2017 - 24
Construction Today - January 2017 - 25
Construction Today - January 2017 - 26
Construction Today - January 2017 - 27
Construction Today - January 2017 - 28
Construction Today - January 2017 - 29
Construction Today - January 2017 - 30
Construction Today - January 2017 - 31
Construction Today - January 2017 - 32
Construction Today - January 2017 - 33
Construction Today - January 2017 - 34
Construction Today - January 2017 - 35
Construction Today - January 2017 - 36
Construction Today - January 2017 - 37
Construction Today - January 2017 - 38
Construction Today - January 2017 - 39
Construction Today - January 2017 - 40
Construction Today - January 2017 - 41
Construction Today - January 2017 - 42
Construction Today - January 2017 - 43
Construction Today - January 2017 - 44
Construction Today - January 2017 - 45
Construction Today - January 2017 - 46
Construction Today - January 2017 - 47
Construction Today - January 2017 - 48
Construction Today - January 2017 - 49
Construction Today - January 2017 - 50
Construction Today - January 2017 - 51
Construction Today - January 2017 - 52
Construction Today - January 2017 - 53
Construction Today - January 2017 - 54
Construction Today - January 2017 - 55
Construction Today - January 2017 - 56
Construction Today - January 2017 - 57
Construction Today - January 2017 - 58
Construction Today - January 2017 - 59
Construction Today - January 2017 - 60
Construction Today - January 2017 - 61
Construction Today - January 2017 - 62
Construction Today - January 2017 - 63
Construction Today - January 2017 - 64
Construction Today - January 2017 - 65
Construction Today - January 2017 - 66
Construction Today - January 2017 - 67
Construction Today - January 2017 - 68
Construction Today - January 2017 - 69
Construction Today - January 2017 - 70
Construction Today - January 2017 - 71
Construction Today - January 2017 - 72
Construction Today - January 2017 - 73
Construction Today - January 2017 - 74
Construction Today - January 2017 - 75
Construction Today - January 2017 - 76
Construction Today - January 2017 - 77
Construction Today - January 2017 - 78
Construction Today - January 2017 - 79
Construction Today - January 2017 - 80
Construction Today - January 2017 - 81
Construction Today - January 2017 - 82
Construction Today - January 2017 - 83
Construction Today - January 2017 - 84
Construction Today - January 2017 - 85
Construction Today - January 2017 - 86
Construction Today - January 2017 - 87
Construction Today - January 2017 - 88
Construction Today - January 2017 - 89
Construction Today - January 2017 - 90
Construction Today - January 2017 - 91
Construction Today - January 2017 - 92
Construction Today - January 2017 - 93
Construction Today - January 2017 - 94
Construction Today - January 2017 - 95
Construction Today - January 2017 - 96
Construction Today - January 2017 - 97
Construction Today - January 2017 - 98
Construction Today - January 2017 - 99
Construction Today - January 2017 - 100
Construction Today - January 2017 - 101
Construction Today - January 2017 - 102
Construction Today - January 2017 - 103
Construction Today - January 2017 - 104
Construction Today - January 2017 - 105
Construction Today - January 2017 - 106
Construction Today - January 2017 - 107
Construction Today - January 2017 - 108
Construction Today - January 2017 - 109
Construction Today - January 2017 - 110
Construction Today - January 2017 - 111
Construction Today - January 2017 - 112
Construction Today - January 2017 - Cover3
Construction Today - January 2017 - Cover4
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/knighthouse/ct_vol17issue6a
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/knighthouse/ct_vol17issue5
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/knighthouse/ct_vol17issue5b
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/knighthouse/ct_vol17issue5a
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/knighthouse/ct_vol17issue4
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/knighthouse/ct_vol17issue4a
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/knighthouse/ct_vol17issue3
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/knighthouse/ct_vol17issue3a
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/knighthouse/ct_vol17issue2
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/knighthouse/ct_vol17issue2a
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/knighthouse/ct_vol17issue1
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/knighthouse/ct_vol17issue1a
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/knighthouse/ct_vol16issue6
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/knighthouse/ct_vol16issue5
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/knighthouse/ct_vol16issue4
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/knighthouse/ct_vol16issue3
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/knighthouse/ct_vol16issue2
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/knighthouse/ct_vol16issue1
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/knighthouse/ct_201712
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/knighthouse/ct_201711
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/knighthouse/ct_20170910
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/knighthouse/ct_20170708
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/knighthouse/ct_201706
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/knighthouse/ct_201705
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/knighthouse/ct_20170304
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/knighthouse/ct_201702
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/knighthouse/ct_201701
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/knighthouse/ct_20161112
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/knighthouse/ct_201610vol2
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/knighthouse/ct_201610
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/knighthouse/ct_201609
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/knighthouse/ct_201608
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/knighthouse/ct_201607
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/knighthouse/ct_201606
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/knighthouse/ct_201605
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/phoenix/ct_201604
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/phoenix/ct_20160304
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/phoenix/ct_20160102
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/phoenix/ct_20151112
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/phoenix/ct_20150910
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/phoenix/ct_20150708
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/phoenix/ct_20150506
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/phoenix/ct_20150304
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/phoenix/ct_20150102
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/phoenix/ct_20141112
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/phoenix/ct_20140910
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/phoenix/ct_20140708
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/phoenix/ct_20140506
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/phoenix/ct_20140304
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/phoenix/ct_20140102
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/phoenix/ct_20131112
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/phoenix/ct_20130910
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/phoenix/ct_20130708
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/phoenix/ct_20130506
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/phoenix/ct_20130304
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/phoenix/ct_20130102
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/phoenix/ct_20121112
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/phoenix/ct_20120910
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/phoenix/ct_201208
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/phoenix/ct_201207
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/phoenix/ct_201206
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/phoenix/ct_201205
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/phoenix/ct_201204
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/phoenix/ct_201203
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/phoenix/ct_201202
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/phoenix/ct_201201
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/phoenix/ct_201112
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/phoenix/ct_20111011
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/phoenix/ct_201109
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/phoenix/ct_201108
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/businessmedia/ct_201107
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/businessmedia/ct_201106
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/businessmedia/ct_201105
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/businessmedia/ct_201104
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/businessmedia/ct_201103
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/businessmedia/ct_201102
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/businessmedia/ct_201101
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/businessmedia/ct_201012
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/businessmedia/ct_201011
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/businessmedia/ct_201010
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/businessmedia/ct_201009
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/businessmedia/ct_201008
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/businessmedia/ct_201007
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/businessmedia/ct_201006
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/businessmedia/ct_201005
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/businessmedia/ct_201004
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/businessmedia/ct_201003
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/businessmedia/ct_201002
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/businessmedia/ct_201001
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/schofield/ct_200912
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/schofield/ct_200911
http://digital.construction-today.com/nxtbooks/schofield/ct_200910
http://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/schofield/ct_200909
http://www.nxtbookMEDIA.com